Aftermarket vs OEM parts for lawn & garden equipment

Posted by Char Smith on

There are lots of aftermarket parts available for lawn and garden equipment - especially for major brands such as Craftsman, Husqvarna, Toro, MTD, Honda, Briggs & Stratton, Tecumseh, and Kohler.

Aftermarket parts can be considerably less expensive than the Original Equipment Manufacturer's (OEM) part. Search a part number and major online shopping sites can give you tons of options at different price points. But should you buy them? The short answer depends.

Stens, Oregon and Rotary

There are three major brands of aftermarket parts in our industry.  Stens, Oregon Power Products, and Rotary Corporation's parts meet or exceed OEM standards.

In some cases, these companies make parts in their factories that are shipped to both aftermarket and OEM distributors.  They get branded or packaged accordingly but they are the same part. Other times, there may be minor alterations such as colour, but the materials and components show no visible difference.

At roughly 1/2 to 3/4 the price of the OEM version, with no important differences in their quality or function, these parts can be very good value. So if you find an Oregon, Stens, or Rotary option is available, rest assured you are getting a quality part.

No-Name Parts

A search of common replacement parts such as filters, blades, and belts returns all kinds of random brands on major online retailers. With fantastic prices, bundles, and deals, the wait for a part to ship from overseas may appear to be a good option. But not all aftermarket parts are created equal.

In the repair shop, we've actually had very little connection with no-name parts over the years.  We deal with major distributors who sell Oregon, Stens, and Rotary aftermarket parts.  When our mechanics are taking out an old dirty air filter, replacing a belt or a broken part, they're not looking too hard at the brand of the old part.

So we ordered a few of these great deals off the internet.  In our very unscientific study, we found three things: the quality was visibly different, the part actually didn't fit, or there were no visible differences. Our unscientific conclusion?  It's a crap shoot.  

Fakes and Counterfeits

A recent Marketplace study by CBC found all kinds of fakes and counterfeits in a wide variety of products purchased from AliExpress, Amazon, eBay, Walmart and Wish.

CBC concluded "More than half of the products Marketplace received were suspected or confirmed counterfeits, with knockoffs found on every platform." They did not purchase any lawn and garden equipment parts; however, it is possible this also affects our industry.

 The Winner

So aftermarket or OEM? Your equipment manufacturer is going to tell you to only use OEM parts in your equipment. Your mechanic or dealer will likely tell you a quality aftermarket part is good value for your dollar.  If you decide to go no-name, check out what consumers are saying online. Search the aftermarket parts brand name for information about their reputation. And remember if the price is too good to be true, that deal might not be the best option.

We Can Help

Still not sure? Contact us for assistance. With more than 10 years buying, selling, and using OEM and aftermarket parts in lawn and garden equipment, we can steer you in the right direction. And rest assured, if we're selling it on our website, it's an real OEM part purchased from a reputable distributor or an aftermarket part with no discernible difference in quality.

DR Mower,,, 1-877-531-2873



Share this post

← Older Post Newer Post →

  • Hello

    Hoping you might be able to help. I have a Sears Craftsman Rotary Lawnmower. # 944.362490. Looking for front wheels .
    Wheel.​8 X 2.​Pr
    Part Number: 180541
    Also rear wheels Part 180183

    I realize Sears has gone out of business unfortunately. But I know some of their Craftsman line of products have been secured by another company. I appreciate your assistance .

    Thank you.


    Henry Holland on

Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published.


0 item(s) in your cart
Subtotal $0.00
View Cart Checkout

View full product info